Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amy Brunvand's avatar

When you say that Paul Kingsnorth is "all over the map" I suppose you mean he has some ideas that seem uncomfortably aligned with conservative politics, yet you still find his ways of overthinking everything compelling. So do I. When I cited Kingsnorth in this essay on Re-Localizing the Library (https://journals.litwinbooks.com/index.php/jclis/article/view/94) the editor called me up to ask if I knew Kingsnorth is a fascist. I said that I know that he has been accused of being a fascist because, yes, folklore can be co-oped as nationalism. However, I also think Kingsnorth is fundamentally right about the value of Prayer, People, Past and Place. I am also sympathetic with his cranky disapproval of surgical/medical body modification because my lived experience in a female body has put me in conflict with a medical system that treats my basically healthy, well-functioning body as a pathology. Wendell Berry also held some uncomfortable conservative views -- for example I do not agree with Berry 's anti-abortion essays. Nonetheless, I moved home and stayed home largely because of Berry's admonition to choose a place and try to form a relationship with that place. He is right about that.

Josh Jackson's avatar

Always enjoy these dispatches. The Goldfarb piece was excellent.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?